My conclusions after researching Nike (NKE) during the week
NKE stock fell 75% while revenue only dropped 10%, offering deep value as the new CEO's turnaround focuses on retail and cost-cutting.
- Stock price dropped 75% from peak while revenue only declined 10%, indicating severe market overreaction and deep value.
- New CEO's strategy to reestablish relationships with major retail chains will boost exposure and drive revenue growth.
- A $2 billion cost-cutting initiative creates a leaner expense structure, significantly boosting profitability on slight sales increases.
- Nike has lost its innovative edge and market share to younger, emerging brands like Hoka, On, and Adidas.
- The previous CEO's failed DTC and tech-focused strategy alienated the core running and athletic community.
I completely understand those who say that Nike has lost its touch and that brands like Hoka, On and Adidas have started to emerge more in America. there is truth in these arguments. But if we put aside the hunting sentiment for a moment and look at the numbers and the story behind them – the picture changes.
Over the past four years, Nike's share price has gradually fallen to a current low of $41.
To get a sense of the market's insanity: The stock is trading at a quarter of its 2021 peak price (which was around $170). The market has simply erased 75% of the value of the world's most powerful sports brand, while revenues have only fallen by about 10% from their peak.
Nike's previous CEO, John Donahue, tried to turn Nike into a technology and direct-to-consumer (DTC) company, cutting ties with major retailers, causing Nike to lose its innovative edge and connection with the running and athletic community. The stock fell, and the company lost market share to younger brands like On and Hoka. Elliot Hill was brought in in October 2024 as the company's "savior" after a very difficult period under John Donahue.
Since taking office, Hill has led a comprehensive turnaround strategy focused on three key axes:
1. A strong return to retail: He quickly reestablished relationships with large retail chains (like Foot Locker and others) that Donahue had abandoned, to put Nike shoes back on shelves everywhere. In my personal opinion, the renewed exposure to the "non-technological" public, such as the 40+ age group, will directly lead to an increase in revenue.
2. Operational diet and a fortified balance sheet: Nike is in the midst of a $2 billion cost-cutting drive. In a sleepy capital market, everyone looks at the top line (revenue) and yawns, but financial statements are not built to reflect revenue alone! In the new lean expense structure, any slight increase of one or two percent in sales (which could emerge as early as this summer thanks to the 2026 World Cup) is going to bounce EPS like a spring loaded.
We’re not talking about a dream stock or a tech company trading at a fantasy P/E and bleeding cash. Nike has one of the strongest balance sheets in the S&P 500 – mountains of cash, debt managed at historically low interest rates, and a dividend yield that, at a floor price of $42, has become a magnet for large institutions. They’re already picking it up under your radar.
3. Investing in innovations and rebuilding morale: As someone who started as an intern in 1988, Hill was a much-loved executive within Nike's corporate culture, and his appointment brought much of the brand's original energy and "DNA" back to employees. He redirected development budgets toward new designs and sports technology, rather than "recycling" existing models. This process takes time because shoe design and manufacturing cycles take months, but it will soon be reflected in stores.
The bottom line: The stock market is an emotional trend machine in the short term, and a value-scavenging machine in the long term. Buying a company with a strong economic moat (as Buffett says) at a 75% discount to its peak while its business fundamentals are being rebuilt is exactly what separates momentary gamblers from patient value investors.
So try to study Nike's reports, understand the numbers, and feel the potential for yourself.
I just drew your attention.
gavrik,
At current price, Nike is still expensive for me. It's facing a lot of competition from the likes of ON, Hoka, New balance. Nike seems to have lost their brand appeal specially among the youth. Unless the new CEO can turn things around, I think Nike still has room to fall further
"Nike seems to have lost their brand appeal specially among the youth" - I begrudgingly agree. There used to be a time when nike was considered a premium shoe - and not for the price - but the product itself - it was a bold statement - an assertion of "coolness".
But it seems, to me atleast, now its just a shoe, among few/many others.
This sub should just be renamed to TerribleInvesting. Most the stocks mentioned here are trash.
What are some stocks you recommend?
Hahahaha yeah really.
It's outright scary
Stock falls since years without any indication of hope: value investment!
Did you use AI to write this?
He used Gemini free account to copy and paste this
It’s not even written
“In a sleepy capital market, everyone looks at the top line (revenue) and yawns, but financial statements are not built to reflect revenue alone!” Yep AI
Too rich for me. I'm looking for value plays. I do have palantir on my watchlist but I haven't researched it
Value is what someone is willing to pay for something. True value is finding companies that are able to disrupt entire industries in ways in which most investors dont yet understand. Palatinr will be worth trillions once people start understanding their true potential. Theres nothing unknown or groundbreaking about Nike. The only thing Nike will disrupt is a flee market.
Just a heads up, Nvidia had a forward PE in the 40s back when it's market cap was roughly 200 billion, its now worth 5 trillion. The company's you listed have forward pes in the 100s, very expensive.
I agree nike isn't going to disrupt anything but they have a defined and growing market with a forward PE in the 20s. It's a lot less risk at these levels. If their earnings get back to 2019 levels the stock will likely double from its current price
Nile has to choose the right role model. It was Michael Jordan. I don’t know who it is now. I don’t know which trainer company will choose the right one going forwards. It goes in my ‘too hard’ pile.
Not sure if this ai slop or not - but your thesis seems valid - my only concern is the attention.
Right now everyone's attention is on the ai pipeline stocks, from bottom (manufacturing) to top (llms).
Nike might as well be a good stock as far as fundamentals are concerned, but market is just looking the other way. Not sure when industry rotation will happen, if at all. Do you have data on hedge funds quietly setting up large positions ?
Except it’s not. P/E still demands a premium
Space - speculation. Medicine - mostly speculation/gambling, technology/ai - mostly speculation (ai returns for hyperscalers yet to prove anything despite backlogs), energy - the only sensible one you mentioned.
Yeah ill stick with buying a shoe company that can turn things around. At least until the market gets its head out of its euphoric ass

r/valueinvesting